• Support Wokingham Today
  • Get the print edition
  • Sign up for our daily newsletter
Thursday, May 29, 2025
Wokingham.Today
  • HOME
  • MY AREA
    • All
    • Arborfield
    • Barkham
    • Beech Hill
    • Binfield
    • Bracknell
    • Charvil
    • Crowthorne
    • Earley
    • Emmbrook
    • Finchampstead
    • Grazeley
    • Henley
    • Hurst
    • Lower Earley
    • Norreys
    • Reading
    • Remenham
    • Riseley
    • Shinfield
    • Sindlesham
    • Sonning
    • Spencers Wood
    • Swallowfield
    • Three Mile Cross
    • Twyford
    • Wargrave
    • Winnersh
    • Wokingham
    • Wokingham Without
    • Woodley
    • Woosehill
    • Yateley
    Dalia's CoppaFeel Curry Night at The Tamarind Tree restaurant was another delicious success for the cancer charity fundraiser. Picture: Emma Merchant

    CoppaFeel Curry Night in Wokingham a joyful fundraiser

    Claire Revie, founder of SHARE Wokingham, helps to create the new brew.

    Special brew to benefit SHARE

    Entries are open for this year's event.

    Enter now for Wokingham Bikeathon

    Sonning bridge. Pic: Google.

    Fine for Sonning weight breach

    This year's event is being held on Saturday, June 14.

    Carnival fun is coming to Woodley

    The Forest School U15s football team

    The Forest School U15s make history with another National Elite Cup victory

    Brecon Road Food and Wine, Woodley Picture: Google Maps

    Woodley store has licence revoked

    Reading Today; 18th March 2023;  Thames Water HQ - Extinction Rebellion protest

    Thames Water issued £123M Ofwat fine–the biggest ever–over environmental breaches

    A banking hub in Yorkshire. Pic: Murray Scott/Link.

    Banking hub plans for village

  • SPORT
    • All
    • Binfield FC
    • Reading FC
    Sell Before We Dai

    Supporters’ Trust at Reading joins 21-group alliance calling for Football Governance Bill amendment

    The Forest School U15s football team

    The Forest School U15s make history with another National Elite Cup victory

    Sam Green and Megan Bartlett, who both took part in the Wokingham half marathon earlier this year. Pic: Harry McBain.

    Sam and Megan take Sumas supporters’ awards

    Reading FC

    Former Reading FC player announces shock international retirement

    Reading FC - Charlie Savage and Harvey Knibbs Picture: Luke Adams

    Reading FC star player linked with transfer to Wrexham

    Sam Hutchinson Picture: Luke Adams

    Former Reading FC reflects on heart attack suffered during match

    FC Bracknell

    FC Bracknell U10 Lions score dramatic winner to win the cup for second season in a row

    Ruben Selles

    Former Reading FC manager Ruben Selles linked with League One job

    Reading FC Picture: Luke Adams

    Reading fans – you can finally dare to dream again

  • READING FC
  • COMMUNITY
    Hands-up: Doreen and Lizzie Picture: WADE Day Care Centre

    Smiles, Songs and Good Company – The Wade Experience

    Dalia's CoppaFeel Curry Night at The Tamarind Tree restaurant was another delicious success for the cancer charity fundraiser. Picture: Emma Merchant

    CoppaFeel Curry Night in Wokingham a joyful fundraiser

    Claire Revie, founder of SHARE Wokingham, helps to create the new brew.

    Special brew to benefit SHARE

    Entries are open for this year's event.

    Enter now for Wokingham Bikeathon

    Sonning bridge. Pic: Google.

    Fine for Sonning weight breach

    This year's event is being held on Saturday, June 14.

    Carnival fun is coming to Woodley

    A grant from The National Lottery Fund will help volunteers at The Eco Skills Learning Centre in Arborfield to create more bird box kits for their children's workshops. PIcture: Spencers Wood Repair Cafe

    Grant means more homes – for the birds

    A banking hub in Yorkshire. Pic: Murray Scott/Link.

    Banking hub plans for village

    Retrospective plans have been refused. Pic: WBC.

    Vending machine plans refused

  • LIFESTYLE
    • All
    • Food
    • Health
    • Obituaries
    • People
    Entries are open for this year's event.

    Enter now for Wokingham Bikeathon

    A government push for more radiotherapy machines has been welcomed by ministers as the Royal Berkshire Hospital is among the services to benefit from them.

    Royal Berks one of 28 Trusts to see new radiotherapy machine investment

    A banking hub in Yorkshire. Pic: Murray Scott/Link.

    Banking hub plans for village

    Retrospective plans have been refused. Pic: WBC.

    Vending machine plans refused

    Mind in Berkshire, which provides support, advice, and signposting for mental health services in Berkshire, was commissioned to examine Black people's access to necessary services, as part of a wider drive from the Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust to address inequalities in local services. Picture: PixaBay

    Mind in Berkshire report finds serious deficits in mental health provisions for Black people

    AB Walker

    VAUGHAN, David Raymond

    The Hope & Anchor. Pic: Rightmove.

    Historic town pub listed for sale

    Woodley Repair Cafe operates on the first Sunday of the month, at Christ Church, Crockhamwell Road, between 2pm and 4pm. Picture: Emma Merchant

    Get things fixed in Woodley

    Photography by: Summers Photography. Flowers by: Fletchers Flowers. Set up by: Crystal Hire.

    Get married and win a wedding at Dinton

  • WHAT’S ON
    • All
    • Arts
    • Entertainment

    REVIEW: “Three Hens In A Boat” at The Watermill Theatre

    Siren RG1

    Siren RG1 to mark first anniversary with weekender celebration

    Wellington Farm Shop

    Wellington Farm Shop celebrates its 20th anniversary

    Two concerts in one day from Reading's APO. Picture: Pexels via Pixabay

    An orchestral event in Wokingham promises evening of drama and contrast

    Eva Wong Nava will be at Trinity Hall Church on Monday from 4pm until 5pm. Picture: Eva Wong Nava

    Young writers can meet children’s author Eva Wong Nava

    Crafters can join a project  to decorate Twyford village centre with bunting Picture: Hello I'm Nik on Unsplash

    Get out the bunting for VE Day at Wokingham’s May Fayre

    Crowthorne Symphony Orchestra's performance of American music promises to be a fun and high energy evening. Picture: CSO

    Discounted tickets available for summer concert in Wokingham

    The Wokingham Lions Club has announced its new season of  #WOKY Comedy Nights at Wokingham Theatre, will begin on Friday, October 4. Picture: Wokingham Lions Club

    Enjoy the last of this season’s #Woky Comedy Night

    A concert at Wokingham Baptist Church will celebrate Ukrainian culture and support charity. Picture: Olena Romanovska

    Wokingham to host a concert of Ukrainian music and dancing

  • JOBS
  • ADVERTISE
  • CONTACT
No Result
View All Result
Wokingham.Today
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

EXCLUSIVE: Hare Hatch Sheeplands owner looks to the future after High Court victory

by Phil Creighton
January 27, 2019
in Featured, Politics, Twyford
Rob Scott

Rob Scott outside Hare Hatch Sheeplands

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Last week, the High Court ruled in favour of Hare Hatch Sheeplands bringing to an end its legal battle with Wokingham Borough Council. PHIL CREIGHTON finds out what it means for both parties

THE WINNER of a High Court battle has said he hopes that the two parties can now put their differences aside and look to a brighter future.

Last week, Wokingham Borough Council lost an ongoing appeal called after Reading Crown Court ruled that it has been unfair and unjust in its treatment of Hare Hatch Sheeplands owner Rob Scott, along with owners of businesses that sublet space from the garden centre.

Reporting restrictions placed on the case last year meant that The Wokingham Paper was unable to report on it, but we are now able to do so.

On June 13, Judge Angela Morris said that the council’s handling of the complex legal case had “only served to make a bad situation worse, especially where they had been in large part the authors of it”.

The council was also criticised for failing to inform Mr Scott and the others for two years that it would prosecute them.

“I regret to say that the approach adopted by Wokingham Borough Council was unfair and unjust,” Judge Morris said last year.

Related posts

VOTE 2024: Live blog from the Wokingham Borough Council elections count

VOTE 2024: Labour can be an effective opposition says its Wokingham leader

The Sheeplands v Wokingham Borough Council case dates back several years and relates to Sheeplands expanding its nursery and farm shop business into becoming a garden centre with associated businesses including an antiques centre, a fishmonger and a double glazing business.

These had been built on protected green belt land and, although Sheeplands had attempted to get appropriate planning permission, Wokingham Borough Council served enforcement notices, forcing the business to downscale.

It also sought to prosecute the businesses for trading there.

Rob Scott in the farm shop

In a long battle between the council and Sheeplands, thousands of members of the public signed a petition of support of the Hare Hatch nursery, which led to a fiery council debate.

On Wednesday last week the High Court agreed with the initial rulings and threw out Wokingham Borough Council’s appeal.

There is no grounds for any further legal action being taken against Sheeplands and now Rob Scott is looking to the future.

Speaking exclusively to The Wokingham Paper, Mr Scott – who launched Sheeplands 25 years ago – said: “I just want to put it behind me and move on.

“It’s a splendid result for a number of reasons: We are no longer threatened by council prosecution. The council can no longer proceed with prosecution or apply to get proceeds of crime.”

“This is why it’s important now for [the council] to engage with us in a positive way. Let the business become what the residents and customers want. We also need to understand what Wokingham Borough Council wants as part of its new local plan.”

Under the consultations, which are currently taking place, Sheeplands has been added to the list of potential sites for housing development, although Mr Scott said he put the site forward under the Council’s ‘call for sites’ as a nursery, garden centre and play area to protect the site. Sheeplands is in the green belt and is protected, although Wokingham Borough Council has been considering a wider housing scheme in the area, along with land in Grazeley and Barkham Square.

“This site has been rolled into the broader east Twyford strategic development location,” he said. “It’s ironic that it could become housing. This is just a part of what’s going on in the local area and we want to engage with Wokingham Borough Council to the benefit of Twyford and Ruscombe residents. We believe it will be nice to engage.”

And with a new leadership coming in to Wokingham Borough Council, including a new chief executive, Mr Scott is optimistic that the broken relationships can be repaired.

“I’ve always felt there is an opportunity for a fresh start, I have to be even more optimistic now and hopefully it will lead to a new approach,” he said.

“We invite Wokingham Borough Council in to discuss what they’d like to see. We can’t survive as just a nursery and with underutilised buildings, particularly with competition everywhere: we’re looking at building a financially sustainable business for the benefit of all people in Wokingham.”

Hare Hatch Sheeplands

He continued: “It’s a real community facility. We currently have an appeal lodged with the planning inspectorate for temporary permission to sell ancillary nursery related products and Christmas trees in the winter when the nursery is quieter.

“The council would not consider our application. We hope that this will help the business grow in the short term and ask the public to write in support to [email protected] quoting reference APP/X0360/W/18/3193969 before February 13.

“In the longer term, we will need to be different as a business in terms of what we can offer, but we can also still maintain our core following.

“Our customers have stayed with us throughout. They miss what is no longer here, but they enjoy things like the new butchers. They started in October, but they took an impressive 250 Christmas orders.”

Wokingham Borough Council said that its success in defending the Green Belt from unauthorised development at Hare Hatch Sheeplands, and its determination to continue that protection, remain unchanged.

Executive member for planning Cllr Simon Weeks said: “The Council has been fighting for many years to successfully preserve the integrity of the Green Belt at Hare Hatch.

“That has not changed, and the Court of Appeal made it clear that the injunction protecting the land remains fully in place. While it is disappointing to have lost this case, the fact remains that there was unlawful development on Green Belt and we put a stop to it.”

Crowds attending the council debate on Hare Hatch Sheeplands on September 1

In WBC’s statement, the Court said it understood the Council’s frustration at Mr Scott’s persistent and longstanding attempts to flout planning control.

However, the Court considered that once other remedies had been successful, including the imposition of a suspended sentence of imprisonment on Mr Scott, the council ought to have further reviewed whether there was public interest in continuing to prosecute Mr Scott and the other defendants.

Cllr Weeks told The Wokingham Paper that the council had been left with no choice but to proceed with legal action because Hare Hatch Sheeplands is on the green belt.

“The council could not simply say, ‘That’s OK, don’t do it again’,” he explained. “The alternative would be the council doing nothing and we have a level of anarchy [in the planning system]. That’s not acceptable.

“In my 15 years’ as a councillor, residents have said that they want planning to be publicly controlled and we cannot be selective as to how we control it.

“Clearly this was a blatant situation.”

And Cllr Weeks is aware that the public has been sympathetic to Mr Scott’s causes.

“Mr Scott clearly has a lot of support from customers but just because it’s popular we can’t say we’ll ignore [breaches of planning consent]. We have to apply the law and that’s what we’ve been trying to do.”

Sheeplands has been compliant with the planning rules for the past 18 months, something that Cllr Weeks acknowledges, and he too is hoping that a new working relationship can be found.

“That’s precisely what we want,” he said, adding that the council would welcome new planning applications from Sheeplands and would consider them as long the meet the appropriate criteria.

“He will have to submit a planning application and the council will scrutinise it, but the council is also obliged to apply national and local planning policies that are stringent on the green belt.

“The bottom line is what he had previously wasn’t acceptable. If Mr Scott can submit something that is acceptable in policy terms, the council will consider it. If it does it differently, then it’s a different matter.”

Since news of the High Court verdict has been made known, some residents have been vocal on social media over the cost involved to the council, with some suggesting that this would be hidden.

However, a spokesperson for Wokingham Borough Council said: “There are some outstanding matters to be determined by the courts so it the final cost is not known”.

Hare Hatch Sheeplands

The Wokingham Paper has not yet seen the High Court judgment and the comments from the courts in this article come from releases issued by both Sheeplands and Wokingham Borough Council.

Keep up to date by signing up for our daily newsletter

We don’t spam we only send our newsletter to people who have requested it.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Tags: Cllr Simon WeeksHare Hatch SheeplandsRob ScottSheeplandsSheeplands v Wokingham Borough COuncilsimon weeksWeeksWokingham Borough Council
Previous Post

Wokingham PR guru Rachel wants you to join her gang

Next Post

SNOW ALERT: Four inches could fall overnight on Tuesday warns Met Office

FOLLOW US

POPULAR THIS WEEK

Retrospective plans have been refused. Pic: WBC.

Vending machine plans refused

May 28, 2025
Very Beautiful South's nine-piece band will play sing-along classics: Perfect 10, Rotterdam, A Little Time and Don?t Marry Her. Picture courtesy of Wokingham Music Club

Beautiful South tribute band to play in Wokingham

May 25, 2025
1 The Parade, credit google maps

Woodley off-licence sale of alcohol to underage children ‘disappointing beyond words’

May 26, 2025
Sonning bridge. Pic: Google.

Fine for Sonning weight breach

May 29, 2025
Toastmasters helps people to enjoy public speaking. The group meets at The Bradbury Centre, Peach Place on the first and third Tuesday of each month. Picture: Matt Botsford via Unsplash

Practise public speaking with Toastmasters

May 23, 2025
The Forest School U15s football team

The Forest School U15s make history with another National Elite Cup victory

May 29, 2025

ABOUT US

Wokingham Today is dedicated to providing news online across the whole of the Borough of Wokingham. It is a Social Enterprise, existing to support the various communities in Wokingham Borough.

Wokingham.Today is a Social Enterprise and aims to ensure that everyone within the Borough has free access to independent and up-to-date news. However, providing this service is not without costs. If you are able to, please make a contribution to support our work.

CONTACT US

[email protected]

Keep up to date with our daily newsletter

We don’t spam we only send our newsletter to people that have subscribed

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

  • Support Us
  • Book Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Get the Print Edition
  • Sign up for our daily newsletter

The Wokingham Paper Ltd publications are regulated by IPSO – the Independent Press Standards Organisation.
If you have a complaint about a  The Wokingham Paper Ltd  publication in print or online, you should, in the first instance, contact the publication concerned, email: [email protected], or telephone: 0118 327 2662. If it is not resolved to your satisfaction, you should contact IPSO by telephone: 0300 123 2220, or visit its website: www.ipso.co.uk. Members of the public are welcome to contact IPSO at any time if they are not sure how to proceed, or need advice on how to frame a complaint.

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • MY AREA
    • Arborfield
    • Barkham
    • Beech Hill
    • Binfield
    • Bracknell
    • Charvil
    • Crowthorne
    • Earley
    • Emmbrook
    • Finchampstead
    • Grazeley
    • Henley
    • Hurst
    • Lower Earley
    • Norreys
    • Reading
    • Remenham
  • COMMUNITY
  • LIFESTYLE
  • SPORT
  • READING FC
  • OBITUARIES
  • WHAT’S ON
  • JOBS
  • PHOTOS
  • ADVERTISE WITH US
  • CONTACT US
  • WHERE TO GET THE PRINT EDITION
  • SUPPORT US

© 2022 - The Wokingham Paper Ltd - All Right Reserved.