Plans to build hundreds of homes on farmland between Twyford and Charvil could still be built despite refusal from the local authority.
Proposals to build 230 homes at Riverways Farm between Twyford and Charvil were rejected by Wokingham Borough Council earlier this year.
Developers David Wilson Homes have since appealed the decision at a hearing which began this week.
An independent government inspectorate could overturn the decision following proceedings.
In June, Wokingham Borough councillors argued that the development would effectively create a new settlement cut off from Twyford, making daily travel difficult for potential residents.
Councillor Wayne Smith said it had taken him 30 minutes to walk from the site to Twyford train station.
Developers argued that it was an ‘ideal location’ for commuters using the train station.
Planning consultant David Murray-Cox said: “Even before the Elizabeth Line opened, Twyford was a sustainable place. But that is now reinforced with more frequent services available to a more diverse range of destinations.”
Plans had proven unpopular with neighbours, with concerns raised on the impact the project would have on sewage, flooding and local schools.
Charvil resident Pat Sutlieff said the site ‘isn’t fit for purpose’.
Like many plans discussed in the Wokingham Borough, residents argued that local amenities could not cope with existing demand – let alone more added with new residents.
Outline approval requests did not include the number of affordable homes to be provided, but planning officers asked that 92 homes be affordable, equating to 40% of the total in the scheme. This would be 14 four-bed, 18-three bed and 28 three-bed houses, along with 14 two-bed and 18 one-bed flats.
David Wilson Homes argued the project would provide a large variety of housing to suit a range of needs. It would also improve walking and cycle connectivity to Twyford and enhance biodiversity.
The company also offered to provide a new rugby ground for Rams RFC, which is currently based off the Old Bath Road outside Sonning.
One main road entrance and exit would be built onto the New Bath Road for residents.
Leader of Wokingham Borough Council and ward member for Twyford, Ruscombe and Hurst, Cllr Stephen Conway, was expected to speak at the hearing.
Other ward members, Martin Alder and Martijin Andrea, were also preparing for the hearing, councillor Conway said.
The government inspectorate has not yet announced when a decision will be made.
